Comments on: Are Bone Broth Protein Powder Benefits Exaggerated?

By: oldbat

oldbat — Mon, 30 Nov 2020 01:57:17 +0000

In reply to oldbat. that would be those OTHER kinds of doctors. ya know the ones with MD after their name.

By: oldbat

oldbat — Mon, 30 Nov 2020 01:56:08 +0000

well first of all a chiropractor is a d.c. aka a DOCTOR of chiropractic. so he IS a dr. just not the kind that kill you (btw, did you the leading cause of death is those kinds of doctors? beats out cancer and heart disease. at least as of a few yrs ago). number two, unless things have changed up, chiropractors get way more training in nutrition than those deadly kinds of doctors. number three, i have been using multi collagen for some time. last week, my brother in law told me i looked younger for some reason. can’t be make up cuz i dont wear it. ymmv.

By: oldbat

oldbat — Sun, 29 Nov 2020 20:07:50 +0000

you have to wonder if bone broth from grain fed animals contains gluten.

By: PETER

PETER — Sat, 28 Nov 2020 21:02:16 +0000

Bone broth protein powder has been a huge help for me.I have many food sensitivities and digest problems. I cannot digest many plant proteins. They have always caused me gas and bloating. Pea, hemp, soy protein do not digest well for me. They exit my body almost looking l8ke they did when I ate them. Both beef and chicken bone broth powder are easily digested by my system and I gained muscle for the first time in years after including it in my diet Thats all the ” health claims” I need to know. Bone broth has a very long history of healing uses. All the modern explanations and claims are just trying to make sense of how it works.

By: Lynn McVicker

Lynn McVicker — Thu, 04 Apr 2019 00:52:15 +0000

i bought bone broth protein and it is making my stomach a mess, I am allergic to gluten n dairy and i am having a hard time finding something that doesn’t hurt my stomach

By: Jeff

Jeff — Fri, 23 Nov 2018 11:03:33 +0000

Have any side effect of this powder? Please let me know!

By: Kelli Thomas

Kelli Thomas — Mon, 29 Jan 2018 00:45:42 +0000

Hello, I am sensitve in general to MSG. Now I have been doing the powdered bone broth for a couple months or more & have experienced foul smelling flatulence to the point where my husband is sick of the smell. Should I stop doing powdered bone broth? Is it hurting my body? I don’t see anything on the labels about MSG so I don’t get it. I lover the taste & would like to keep taking it. Is there something I can take with the bone broth to make the foul flatulence go away? Thanks for aNY advice you can give me.

Kelli

By: Dave Clark

Dave Clark — Sat, 30 Dec 2017 16:34:39 +0000

I use the Great Lakes Collagen Hydrosylate. i don’t see anywhere on the label in the ingredient list where it shows glucosamine or chondroitin . Are you saying ‘all’ collagen is going to contain G and C regardless of the label?

I have heard on forums about people who react to the glutamic acid in the bone broth powders (collagen), and wondered whether it was worth even using it.
I am new to your website, great information!

By: Soraya L.

Soraya L. — Thu, 28 Dec 2017 11:19:22 +0000

By the way, it’s not hard or that expensive to make bone broth from scratch, especially chicken. It just takes a bit of preparation and cooking time.
And you can avoid all fractionated aminos, MSG, “natural flavor”, mad-cow-prion byproducts from a dodgy slaughterhouse 10000 miles away, etc.
There are many recipes online about how to make your own.
(You will want to read around and get a lot of tips if you are going to try to make beef broth from beef bones – apparently they should be roasted first or something, or it gets really smelly during the process;
or something like that — I myself haven’t tried to make anything but chicken bone broth/stock.)
—
It is true that a normal, old-fashioned, homemade bone broth/stock has minerals and other healthy stuff in it that isn’t that common in our modern “Western” diet, and there isn’t much downside to having some every once in a while (unless you are sensitive to histamines and things like that).

By: Soraya L.

Soraya L. — Thu, 28 Dec 2017 11:05:55 +0000

This must have been written by someone who does not have bad reactions to foods, supplements, plants, household chemicals, etc.! I.e., “…many of these adverse reactions people proposed remain theoretical and unproven”… and it’s repeated twice that the consumer claims of problems with this product (and products like it, from many different brands, not just picking on Josh Axe’s product) were “theoretical and unproven” — well, if there are hundreds of purchasers who have taken the time to write reviews saying things like, “I drank this product and immediately I got a rash over half my body” (or whatever negative issue they might have claimed seemed to them to come about directly as a result of using this product), maybe they are telling the truth about their own experiences, maybe these are not “hypothetical and unproven” reactions, just because there isn’t an an article in PubMed about a double-blind peer-reviewed large-group randomized controlled study that has looked into unwanted side effects of this specific product in a diet-controlled laboratory setting.
—
I always strongly suspect that anything with hydrolyzed amino acids and various other protein-powder-y ingredients, even if it doesn’t explicitly say “MSG” or the hundred other ways tricksy food ingredients can be depicted on a food label, is going to make me feel sick – give me a headache, stomachache, probably a rash — because, over the years, and I’m not a spring chicken (ha), all of such items that I have tried always have done so. I simply can’t handle this sort of stuff. I can’t even do gelatin, even the organic “natural” stuff that’s in the red or blue can, without several unpleasant reactions. My body just does not like this sort of thing. And my experience is not that uncommon.
So when people who’ve never really tried this kind of thing before do try it — with a lot of hope and good intentions, and having spent a lot of cash and time to obtain it — and then take the time to return to the site they purchased it from to leave a comment describing their bad personal experience with it, if they don’t seem like a random troll or something, there is no reason to assume that they are completely wrong about their bodies’ reactions to the product.